Myanmar refugees in Bangladesh, the politics of their situation is more important than the human impact
In October of 2009, the government of Bangladesh received a report from its military officials detailing a credible threat of attack from Myanmar, they feared that St Martin’s island in the Bay of Bengal, a region increasingly important economically for hydrocarbons, would be attacked and captured by Myanmar, and called for the government to strengthen the defensive capability of the island which has a circumference of just 3 miles.
Now Myanmar has proposed that the sea border between the two countries should be re-drawn and moved closer to the island, a proposal that Bangladesh has opposed, and has asked for the support of India and the UN in this regard.
The island is an important tourist destination and has proven extremely lucrative for a number of Bangladesh-based cruise lines as well as for the locals on the islands itself. The number of visitors each year has increased significantly, and its surrounding waters have been found to contain rich deposits of hydrocarbons.
The island is important to Bangladesh then, and an unnamed government official told Bangladesh news media that “Bangladesh will now weigh the new proposal of Myanmar.”
This is in addition to reports by Bangladesh news media that the countries border guards have accused the Myanmar military of frequently crossing the border into Bangladesh and carrying out operations aimed at separatist groups seeking refuge in Bangladesh.
The situation between the two countries is tense then, so tense that the further accommodation of refugees from the military dictatorship cannot be tolerated. It has been found that refugees from a Muslim tribe called the Rohingyas, which is mercilessly persecuted in Myanmar, are now being persecuted in Bangladesh as well, although in a more indirect capacity.
Physicians for Human Rights (PHR), an humanitarian group operating in Bangladesh has claimed that Rohingyas refugees have been forced into refugee camps close to the Myanmar border in Cox's Bazar, and are being forced to remain in these “open air prisons” while they slowly starve to death.
These people are not recognized by Myanmar as citizens, and are forced into a slave-like labour arrangement and are arbitrarily arrested and beaten, while Bangladesh does not recognize them as credible refugees. They therefore occupy a space that the philosopher Agamben might have called the space of the exception, they are not part of Myanmar or Bangladesh and so they are not within any legal framework and are not entitled to the benefits of citizenship, such as the protection of their human rights.
A report issued by Physcians for Humanitarian Rights said that the government of Bangladesh was “systematically rounding up, jailing or summarily expelling these unregistered refugees across the Myanmar border in flagrant violation of the country's human rights obligations”.
Human rights are touted as inalienable, but they are only thus classified if governments see them as such. People such as the Rohingyas are not protected by these laws because their human rights have been eclipsed by something much greater: politics.
Bangladesh does not want to acknowledge the refugees, and instead calls them economic migrants, because they do not want to make them their responsibility, and do not want to create a mass exodus from Myanmar, which would surely provoke the military junta that has already indicated it wants some of Bangladesh’s territory.
Instead they will be ignored by one country and persecuted by another, while organizations such as the PHR and the toothless UN struggle to find a way to recognize the human rights of a people of many whose humanity is recognized by few.
Comments
More Bangladesh News
RSS-
A Bangladesh factory that obeys the rules
Set aside for a moment what you think you know about the garment factories in Bangladesh: grimy, sweaty, children sitting in dimly lit, sweltering rooms sewing shirts you buy at your box store for ...
-
Bangladesh bosses hail safety deal
Bangladesh labour activists and manufacturers have welcomed plans by foreign retailers to improve shocking safety standards at garment factories after a disaster which killed over 1,100 workers.The retailers' promise followed last month's collapse of a nine-storey factory complex outside Dhaka that killed 1,127 people in one of the world's worst industrial disasters.Labour ...
-
Teargas used on Dhaka textile workers
Rescue workers look for trapped garment workers in the collapsed Rana Plaza building in Savar, 30km outside Dhaka, in this April 26, 2013, file ...
-
Bangladesh has one-month ban on rallies
Bangladeshi authorities have announced a one-month ban on political rallies to facilitate relief operations after Cyclone Mahasen.'It is not possible to protect the fundamental rights like holding meetings and rallies when the country was hit by a natural disaster,' Local Government and Cooperatives Minister Syed Ashraful Islam told reporters in the capital Dhaka.The category-one ...
-
17 killed 30 injured in road accident in Bangladesh
At least 17 people were killed and about 30 others injured as a goods laden truck and a night passenger bus collided head on in Bangladesh's Shajahanpur sub- district of Bogra district, 197 km northwest of the capital Dhaka, on Thursday morning.Police was quoted by private news agency UNB as saying that the Dhaka bound truck collided head on with the passenger bus, leaving 11 passengers ...
-
Bangladesh garment hub to reopen
Bangladesh garment manufacturers said they would reopen hundreds of factories in a manufacturing hub outside the capital, days after they shut the plants due to worker unrest following a deadly accident.The manufacturers on Monday announced the shutdown of the factories in the Ashulia industrial area after two weeks of protests over the death of 1,127 garment workers in the country's worst ...
-
Bangladesh Myanmar suffer with cyclone
A cyclone ripped into the Bangladeshi coast Thursday as hundreds of thousands of people hunkered down in evacuation shelters, including in a region of Myanmar torn by communal unrest.Two people died as Cyclone Mahasen hit Bangladesh's southern Patuakhali coast, officials said, while heavy rains and strong winds also lashed neighbouring Myanmar's northwest coast, home to tens of ...
-
Bangladesh factories close indefinitely
Hundreds of factories which form the hub of Bangladesh's garment industry are to close indefinitely after worker unrest sparked by the death of more than 1100 colleagues, employees say.As the search for bodies from last month's building collapse wrapped up, the textile industry's main trade body said all operations at the nearby Ashulia industrial zone on the outskirts of Dhaka ...
-
Bangladesh unlikely to retain preferential treatment in the US market
The prospects of Bangladesh retaining the generalised system of preferences (GSP) in the US market are bleak, according to Commerce Minister GM Quader."After the Rana Plaza collapse, expecting a positive result from the USTR [United States Trade Representative] hearing has become difficult," Quader told The Daily Star yesterday. "I cannot exactly say whether the outcome will be ...
-
Bangladeshi opposition leader says govt ban on political rallies stalls talks
Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) Chairperson Khaleda Zia has said the dialogue between the government and the opposition would be "affected" by the government's "ban" on holding rallies for a month.She made the comment when a delegation of ambassadors called on her at her Gulshan office last night.The delegation included William Hanna, head of EU delegation to ...
-
Mobile banking helps Bangladesh economy grow
Around 1.12 billion Bangladeshi taka (US$14.21 million) is being transacted through mobile banking services in Bangladesh every day on an average, helping the economy grow further by transferring money from urban to rural areas, Bangladesh Bank Governor Atiur Rahman said yesterday.Banks have been providing mobile financial services to 5 million people through around 7,000 agents across the ...
-
UN human rights chief welcomes building and fire safety accord in Bangladesh
The United Nations human rights chief has called for further actions to improve the working conditions of the Bangladeshi garment sector."We welcome the fact that dozens of international companies have made a legal commitment to improve safety in Bangladesh's garment factories, in the wake of last month's building collapse that killed more than 1,127 people," Navanethem ...
-
Banned Bangladesh Factory Still Operates
VF Corp. VF confirmed on Saturday it was still using Liz Apparels to make its clothing following an inspection ordered by the factory owner, Nassa Group, on May 12. VF, whose other clothing brands include North Face, Timberland and Nautica, said its philosophy was to "stay and improve" working conditions."We are in daily contact with the facility and VF's leadership is ...
-
Exclusive Bangladesh factory banned by Wal-Mart still makes Wrangler shirts
GAZIPUR, Bangladesh (Reuters) - A Bangladesh factory where Wal-Mart Stores Inc and Inditex SA inspectors spotted cracks in the wall this month is still making Wrangler shirts for the world's largest apparel maker, U.S.-based VF ...
-
Factory owner banned from leaving Bangladesh
DHAKA, Bangladesh // The High Court in Bangladesh's capital asked authorities yesterday to prevent the owner of a garment factory where 112 people died in a fire last year from leaving the country, a lawyer said. The High Court made the request in response to a petition seeking the arrest of Delwar Hossain, the owner of Tazreen Fashions Ltd. It also asked authorities to bring Hossain ...
-
Hema Zeeman dont sign Bangladesh textile industry safety deal
Dutch high street brands Hema, Zeeman, Prenatal and Coolcat have not signed an agreement to improve safety and working conditions for textile workers in Bangladesh, according to the final list of signatories published online. C&A, V&D, G-Star and WE have signed up to ...
-
Garment factory owner barred from leaving Bangladesh
Bangladesh's top court on Sunday ordered police to prevent the owner of a garmentfactory that catered to top Western retailers from leaving the country, six months after 111 of his employees died in a ...
-
Bangladesh court orders action against factory owner in Nov fire
Delwar Hossain, owner of the Tazreen Fashions garment factory, where 112 workers died in a devastating fire last month, speaks during an interview at the office of the Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers & Exporters Association (BGMEA) in Dhaka November 29, ...
Bangladesh in Focus
-
Myanmar refugees in Bangladesh, the politics of their situation is more important than the human impact
Bangladesh and Myanmar have been disputing their sea border for years, and in recent months tensions on the land border have mounted as claims of interference and counter-claims of provocation are made by both countries, now the politics of territorial dispute have come to have a direct bearing on the respect for human life and development.
In October of 2009, the government of Bangladesh received a report from its military officials detailing a credible threat of attack from Myanmar, they feared that St Martin’s island in the Bay of Bengal, a region increasingly important economically for hydrocarbons, would be attacked and captured by Myanmar, and called for the government to strengthen the defensive capability of the island which has a circumference of just 3 miles. Read more
News from around our Network
